We’re seeing some really big strides in the business (and revenue) model shifts in the accounting profession. At this writing, FIVE of the US Top 100 largest CPA firms, and several Top 200 firms, are currently instituting Fore’s Advanced Pricing Methods℠. These brave large firms are on the very front end of the innovation curve: the pace at which new ideas are spread or diffused.
In her recent article about Changing the Business Model, INSIDE Public Accounting’s editor Chris Camara did an amazing job summarizing what’s happening, why (what’s driving changes), and some of my thoughts on how you can get started on a new pricing approach.
Here’s a snip (click on article thumbnail for the full piece):
Within the last few years, firm leaders have begun accepting that a new revenue model is inevitable, spurred by the rapid introduction of time- saving technologies. Since fewer hours mean reduced WIP-based billings, firm leaders are implementing – or at least investigating – different revenue methods that capture each solution’s worth, not the time spent on it, which is irrelevant as far as the client is concerned.
The impact of work speed on traditional billing is already being felt, says River. One East Coast firm, for example, implemented data analytics and reduced time spent on one aspect of audit from five hours to about 15 minutes. If an hours-X-fee system is used, the time reduction across hundreds of clients means a serious revenue deficit, River says. Another example is an IPA 200 firm that implemented Lean Six Sigma techniques and a workflow product that reduced tax preparation time up to 50% in some cases. Without another revenue model in place first, even after adding clients, they had a $900,000 shortfall between their 2017 and 2018 WIP.
If you’re interested in more “how to” check out my half-day workshop on Nov 5, 2019 in Indianapolis at the 2019 PRIME Symposium. This workshop is open to the public and is limited to 50 guests. Contact email@example.com for details!
My friend Greg Kyte is one of my favorite customer experience experts. Maybe it’s because of his authenticity? Or maybe it’s his ability to relate seemingly unrelated things. Whatever it is, he REALLY gets it.
(If you’ve been through any of my pricing workshops, you’ve probably “met” Greg via one of his outstanding videos like the Billable Hour Scratch & Win.)
Well today, I stumbled on a post he wrote about how buyers value different things. Enjoy this story about angry grandpas and tea-cup style spinny rides: The Value Conversations and LegoLand.
Rogue 24 is a new DC restaurant that is apparently so worried about no-shows that it has a two-page contract for would-be patrons. Their terms require payment for cancellations within 72 hours among other (obnoxious) things. For some, the sense of exclusivity (and jerkiness) might actually be a draw, but last time I checked, restaurants were considered part of the “hospitality” industry and there is nothing hospitable about their approach.
I know a lot of CPA firms who are sick to death of clients not being ready for them when they show up for audit fieldwork. (This post uses audit as an example, but the concepts apply to consulting, website development, and a zillion other types of projects.)
I can’t blame a firm for being frustrated when the audit team arrives for fieldwork day one and the advance PBC (prepared-by-client) list has not been completed. It’s expensive and it’s disruptive. And let’s face it, it’s pretty inconsiderate of you and your time which is unprofessional.
The auditors either leave with unanticipated open time in the middle of what is typically a jam-packed audit season, or they simply begin to “help” the client get ready. But in doing so without a signed change request, the firm will likely end up writing off the work. Or worse, the firm will later “bill and duck” for this work at high risk of angering the client.
And next year, when the client is not ready again, the firm is … wait for it … surprised. And annoyed.
Congrats to this firm—they have successfully trained the client that the PBC list and the work schedule aren’t important enough to be respected or adhered to.
Feeling taken advantage of, and still not realizing it’s partly their own fault, some firms contemplate “policies” that penalize a client for not abiding by the schedule. Perhaps they resemble Rogue 24’s policy, and seem just as welcoming?
There are much better ways to set expectations and prevent such scheduling disruptions whether for audits or any work that needs to be organized well in advance with appropriately skilled people during very specific time periods.
Sit on the same side of the table as your customer.
I’m not the least bit against a monetary penalty for lack of readiness. In fact, I believe timing of work should play a huge role in determining your prices. Timing is usually critical to the client and duration (a maximum) is nearly always going to be essential to your profitability.
But it’s not hospitable to shove an ugly contract in your current or prospective customer’s face demanding compliance with your terms. Doing so creates an adversarial relationship with the customer. (Sorta like billing and ducking does.)
Instead, put some energy into learning details about your customer’s exact needs, educating them where it is helpful to both of you, and doing everything possible to help them be ready for you on the day you are going to show up to begin that work.
The best tone to take is “help us help you.”
1. Give exact dates.
Be very, very clear about timing in your project quotes (or proposals or statements of work or customer-service agreements — whatever you choose to call them). Many firms take a lazy approach and simply say “30 days before the reporting date” or “30 days after fiscal year end.”
Egads, if you don’t care enough about the dates to list them, why would you think your client will care enough to honor them?
Don’t ever make the customer calculate any “PBC” due dates! They won’t.
Do the legwork and tell them the actual dates. Better yet, include a visual. Show them key dates, don’t just bury them in text.
Say what is needed, when, by whom, and delivered to whom.
2. Teach them how.
Do you want to win some points for being extra helpful? And do have you have an ulterior motive to make sure it’s done right? Of course you do! And that’s all right.
Informally talk with them. Show them samples. Provide templates.
Maybe you can offer some formal classes on preparing PBC list items. Education is a terrific complimentary service that you could offer as part of the engagement or charge extra for it. Perhaps new clients get to attend the first one free. Or every client gets one admission included and additional people are extra.
3. Provide reminders. Early and often.
Customers appreciate your reminder postcards, phone calls, and emails. They show you care and they emphasize that you’re serious about timing and readiness.
This can be done by your admin team on a systematic schedule: a week before fieldwork, two weeks before, 30 days before, 60 days before, etc.
“How’s your PBC list coming along?” “Do you have any questions for us?” “Don’t forget, we’ll be there Monday the 23rd.” “Call us right away if you have any concerns about being ready two weeks from tomorrow. Now’s the time to let us know!”
4. Show you’re serious.
Of course there can and should be a stated consequence to lack of readiness if that should occur after all the education and reminders.
In your project quotes, describe how you’ll do everything in your power to help them be ready. Show you are committed to helping them help you help them (did you follow that?). Tell them you share their goal for a successful project and that in order to meet their desired delivery timing, these [list] things need to happen on these [list] dates.
Tell them that in the unfortunate event that you don’t get adequate notice about a date change (two weeks might be reasonable for adjusting an audit schedule) that there will be a $1,000 (or $5,000 or $10,000) rescheduling charge and that their audit would then need to be bumped back to the end of the month (or quarter or year).
And be very clear, in advance, about extra charges (state how much they’ll pay for commonly delayed items) for assisting onsite with incomplete PBC work if you even have the time available to perform the work and still meet the agreed-upon delivery timing. This makes obtaining approved change requests a lot easier because the pricing was already spelled out.
When you provide your reminders, remind them that you don’t want them to incur these charges or delay their audit and that’s why you’re being such a stickler about timing.
You can also consider offering rewards for readiness such as “customers who are ready for us will get priority scheduling next year” with first pick of dates which, of course, implies the opposite as a consequence for lack of readiness.
Training is hard and retraining is harder.
What you are trying to do with all of this is to gain advance knowledge about lack of readiness so you can properly manage and adjust your clients’ expectations about price and delivery. And, of course, manage your own scheduling (second to managing client expectations).
Don’t budge on your extra charges or rescheduling. Just like parenting, it takes confidence and guts to stick to our guns during the retraining process, but we have to do it to correct the problems we have created and to be taken seriously. The very first time you are inconsistent, you defeat your purpose and have to start all over again.
If you apply these principles with “love” and care (e.g., “it’s for your benefit … we don’t want you to go over budget … help us help you”) by sitting on the same side of the table rather than coming across as though they work for you, clients can respect and appreciate you in the process of following your approach to serving them.
And they might even prefer to dine with you.
This is a repeat of a popular article from my Golden Practices blog (originally posted in 2011) which has many other articles on customer service, pricing and lots of other CPA-firm topics.